Current:Home > InvestWestern Coal Takes Another Hit as Appeals Court Rules Against Export Terminal -EverVision Finance
Western Coal Takes Another Hit as Appeals Court Rules Against Export Terminal
View
Date:2025-04-15 01:28:24
A Washington state appeals court has ruled against a company that wants to build the largest coal export terminal in the country on the Columbia River. The decision could be a fatal blow for a controversial project that could have increased global greenhouse gas emissions.
Western states with coal mining operations have been pushing for an export terminal that would allow them to send their coal by rail to the coast and then ship it to China.
A coal terminal was proposed on the banks of the Columbia River in Longview, Washington, but the state opposed it on several grounds. State officials rejected a water quality permit under the Clean Water Act, pointing to a long list of environmental harms, including air pollution from the coal trains. They also rejected a plan to sublease state-owned land for the coal terminal, citing concerns about the company’s finances and reputation, including that it had misrepresented just how much coal it planned to ship.
The appeals court ruled on the state’s rejection of the sublease on Tuesday, saying the Department of Natural Resources had acted reasonably given the circumstances.
“It’s yet another nail in the coffin of a project that faces legal, market and financial challenges,” said Clark Williams-Derry, director of energy finance for the Sightline Institute, an environmental think tank based in Seattle. “If this were built, it would be a massive increase in the emissions attributable to economic activity in Washington state. We are closing our own coal fired power plant within six years, the notion that at the same time we would be enabling the construction of others around the globe doesn’t make climate sense.”
Kristin Gaines, Senior Vice President of Regulatory Affairs for Millennium Bulk Terminals-Longview, the company behind the proposed project, said the company would continue to fight for the project.
“The Court of Appeals got it wrong and we will explore all available remedies, legal and otherwise, to continue to move our project forward,” Gaines said.
Company ‘Intentionally Concealed’ Plan’s Extent
The state court of appeals reversed a ruling by a superior court, which had determined that the state Department of Natural Resources (DNR) had acted arbitrarily and capriciously when it denied the sublease of state-owned land to Millennium.
“DNR’s careful consideration of Millennium’s financial condition and business reputation was especially reasonable given the circumstances surrounding the potential sublease,” the appellate court judges wrote in their decision. “At the time DNR made its decision, coal market conditions were not promising, with U.S. coal production dropping.” Millennium’s corporate parent, Ambre Energy, also sold its interest in Millennium, and Millennium’s other corporate parent, Arch Coal, filed for bankruptcy, the judges wrote.
The original permit request was also for an export facility capable of handling about 5 million metric tons of coal per year. However, internal company records showed it planned to build a much larger terminal with an annual capacity of 20 to 60 million metric tons, said Marisa Ordonia, an attorney for Earthjustice representing environmental groups who intervened in the case.
“Millennium intentionally concealed the extent of its plans for the coal export facility in order to avoid full environmental review,” the judges wrote in their decision. “DNR had significant, well founded reasons for carefully considering the financial condition and business reputation of Millennium before consenting to sublease.”
Since the project was first proposed in 2010, the price of coal has decreased significantly, dropping from approximately $85 per ton to roughly $50 per ton for similar quality coal.
Trump Takes Aim at Clean Water Act Rules
Another key challenge to the project is a Clean Water Act permit that the Washington Department of Ecology denied in 2017.
The coal terminal was one of several fossil fuel energy projects denied Clean Water Act permits by states in recent years. Those moves prompted the Trump administration to propose changes to the Clean Water Act earlier this month that would limit state authority.
Any potential changes to the act wouldn’t impact the 2017 ruling but could limit state authority in future decisions, Jan Hasselman, an attorney with Earthjustice said.
“I think there will be a big fight over this for future projects,” he said, “but I don’t think they have any impact on the projects that have already been denied.”
Published Aug. 22, 2019
veryGood! (7832)
Related
- Civic engagement nonprofits say democracy needs support in between big elections. Do funders agree?
- Disney is raising prices on ad-free Disney+, Hulu — and plans a crackdown on password sharing
- The live action 'The Little Mermaid' is finally coming to streaming—here's how to watch
- $8.5 billion acquisition puts fashion giants Versace, Coach and Michael Kors under one company
- What to watch: O Jolie night
- How to help those affected by the Maui wildfires
- U.S. nurse Alix Dorsainvil and daughter released after kidnap in Haiti, Christian group says
- Iconic Lahaina banyan tree threatened by fires: What we know about Maui's historic landmark
- Tree trimmer dead after getting caught in wood chipper at Florida town hall
- Kenosha police arrested a Black man at Applebee’s. The actual suspects were in the bathroom
Ranking
- The city of Chicago is ordered to pay nearly $80M for a police chase that killed a 10
- Former Catholic priest admits to sexual misconduct with 11-year-old boy he took on beach vacation
- Brody Jenner, fiancée Tia Blanco welcome first child together: 'Incredibly in love'
- Iowa motorist found not guilty in striking of pedestrian abortion-rights protester
- McConnell absent from Senate on Thursday as he recovers from fall in Capitol
- San Francisco has lots of self-driving cars. They're driving first responders nuts
- UPS says drivers to make $170,000 in pay and benefits following union deal
- Las Vegas police videos show moments before home is raided in Tupac Shakur cold case
Recommendation
Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
Amazon founder Jeff Bezos buys home in Miami’s ‘billionaire bunker.’ Tom Brady will be his neighbor
Here's where inflation stands today — and why it's raising hope about the economy
Pink baby! Fan goes into labor at Boston concert, walks to hospital to give birth to boy
At site of suspected mass killings, Syrians recall horrors, hope for answers
Paramore cancels remaining US tour dates amid Hayley Williams' lung infection
Don't call it 'vegan' and other tips from hospitals to get people to eat less meat
Teen Social Media Star Lil Tay Confirms She's Alive And Not Dead After Hoax