Current:Home > NewsSouth Carolina Supreme Court to decide if new private school voucher program is legal -EverVision Finance
South Carolina Supreme Court to decide if new private school voucher program is legal
View
Date:2025-04-17 16:50:20
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — The South Carolina Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday on whether a law passed last year allowing parents to spend taxpayer money on private schools violates part of the he state constitution banning direct aid to anything other than public schools.
But even as the justices ponder the case, lawmakers in the House are looking to expand the program beyond the law’s provision for vouchers of up to $6,000 for up to 15,000 students a year.
The case centers on the part of the South Carolina’s constitution that says “no money shall be paid from public funds nor shall the credit of the State or any of its political subdivisions be used for the direct benefit of any religious or other private educational institution.”
Lawyers who think the program is illegal said giving the private schools public money is a direct benefit even if the program allows students to pay fees or transportation to attend a public school outside of their district.
“It’s all in a trust fund – it’s all in a state controlled trust fund,” attorney Ramya Ravindran told the justices.
But supporters of the new law said the trust fund is key. The money goes to parents, who get to make a decision on where to spend it instead of state government directly paying the private schools themselves.
“The Rosetta Stone of this case is to figure out who the direct beneficiary is,” said Jim Gilliam, an attorney for Republican House Speaker Murrell Smith.
Smith last week proposed a bill that would make the program open to all students, eliminating by 2027 what was going to be a $120,000 family income cap and a cap on 2% of the school age population, or about 15,000 students.
The bill that would also eliminate state audits for private schools getting the money and not require them to give their students the same standardized tests as public school students as a comparison passed a subcommittee Tuesday and will likely head to the House floor Thursday.
Senate Majority Leader Shane Massey said last week he wants to see what the state Supreme Court says and give the program some time to operate before changing things.
“Before you look at expanding it, you need to makes sure this one is going to work,” Massey said.
The law is part of a nationwide movement. Groups that study the programs report that as many as 16 states have some form of the vouchers.
A second possible problem with the South Carolina law for supporters is the law has the state Education Superintendent running the program. The constitution calls her the “chief administrative officer of the public education system.” The state says that doesn’t prohibit her from expanding her duties.
“How can the legislature require that individual get involved in private education?” asked James Lockemy, a retired Court of Appeals chief judge sitting in on this case.
Allowing parents to spend public money on private schools has been a two decade effort that ran through three governors, four House speakers and five education superintendents in a state where Republicans have been consolidating and expanding their power.
The justices Tuesday peppered both sides with questions. Chief Justice Donald Beatty was especially skeptical of the new law, mentioning an earlier state Supreme Court ruling that the governor could not send COVID relief money directly to private schools.
“Obviously, we weren’t convincing then, were we?” Beatty said introducing Wednesday’s case.
Later, Education Department attorney Miles Coleman said no private school sees the new money as a benefit when a state agency gets additional oversight and access to their books.
“This money isn’t even enough to cover what we think is the cost as a state of education. It’s not some sort of largess or boon to the recipient,” Coleman said of the program’s $90 million price tag.
“$90 million is not a boon?” asked Beatty, who earlier in the arguments said that would be enough money to hire 2,200 public school teachers, adding “yet we want to shift all this money to private schools to keep them afloat.”
The justices made no decision Wednesday and will issue a ruling at a later date.
veryGood! (4)
Related
- The White House is cracking down on overdraft fees
- Horoscopes Today, July 22, 2024
- Plane crash kills two near EAA Airventure Oshkosh 2024 on first day
- Israel shoots down missile fired from Yemen after deadly Israeli strike on Houthi rebels
- Grammy nominee Teddy Swims on love, growth and embracing change
- Coca-Cola raises full-year sales guidance after stronger-than-expected second quarter
- New Federal Grants Could Slash U.S. Climate Emissions by Nearly 1 Billion Metric Tons Through 2050
- Sam Smith couldn't walk for a month after a skiing accident: 'I was an idiot'
- US appeals court rejects Nasdaq’s diversity rules for company boards
- Josh Hartnett Makes Rare Comment About His Kids With Tamsin Egerton
Ranking
- IRS recovers $4.7 billion in back taxes and braces for cuts with Trump and GOP in power
- 2024 Olympics: A Guide to All the Couples Competing at the Paris Games
- 3 Army Reserve officers disciplined after reservist killed 18 people last October in Maine
- Officials release video of officer fatally shooting Sonya Massey in her home after she called 911
- What do we know about the mysterious drones reported flying over New Jersey?
- Billion-dollar Mitsubishi chemical plant economically questionable, energy group says
- Foreign leaders react to Biden's decision not to seek reelection
- MLB trade deadline: Should these bubble teams buy or sell?
Recommendation
Federal court filings allege official committed perjury in lawsuit tied to Louisiana grain terminal
Delta faces federal investigation as it scraps hundreds of flights for fifth straight day
Blake Lively Quips She’d Be an “A--hole” If She Did This
Fourth Wing TV Show Reveals New Details That Will Have You Flying High
Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
Hiker missing for 2 weeks found alive in Kentucky's Red River Gorge after rescuers hear cry for help: Truly a miracle
Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively Reveal Name of Baby No. 4
Silicon Valley-backed voter plan for a new California city won’t be on the November ballot after all